Wednesday, September 29, 2010

Elizabeth Gaskell Bicentenary Blog Tour: Cranford (2007) – Movie Review

Welcome to the Elizabeth Gaskell Bicentenary Blog Tour, sponsored by Laurel Ann at  I hope you have an educational and entertaining experience as you visit the various sites along the way!

Unlike most of the blog tour participants, I haven’t read a word of Mrs. Gaskell’s work.  Until recently, I’d never heard of her.  Then the miniseries Cranford and Return to Cranford came to PBS with much acclaim from critics and adoration from fans.  With all the excitement surrounding these broadcasts, I considered taking a look to see if they really were all they were cracked up to be.  But my cursory examination of the production falsely led me to believe that it was just another period piece with silly women in bonnets flitting about.

When Laurel Ann invited me to the tour, I decided to give the series a try.  This author seems to be so beloved by those who know her, and this tour confirms for me the important place that she holds in literature.  So off to the public library I went, where they had a 2-disc edition of the BBC’s production of Cranford.

I had some time on a Saturday and hoped I’d get at least one of the 60-minute episodes watched while my guys were out of the house for a bit and I could watch in peace.  To my utter astonishment, not only did I end up having 5 hours free time, but I watched the entire series that day!  Needless to say, I loved this program.  Here’s an overview of the episodes, and I’ll do my best to avoid spoilers for those who haven’t seen them:

Episode 1:  June 1842

Lovely introduction!  I felt like I was in a Jane Austen novel. What a quaint little English town Cranford is.  It’s calm and peaceful, not even requiring a police force to keep order. Possibly the most dysfunctional aspect of it all were the well-meaning but silly busybodies running about spreading rumors and getting their facts mixed up all the time.  I had previously thought that all these “chickens” would annoy me, but they were quite funny and entertaining.  This was especially true of the hysteria-prone Miss Octavia Pole, played by Imelda Staunton.  Her moment with the cat and the lace was just hysterical.

While there were many moments of laughter in this episode, dramatic scenes brought plenty of levity to the program.  We see the struggles of the poor in the community, one of the residents is shockingly injured, and a mother longs for her rarely-seen son.  One of the main characters suffers a devastating loss, and the manner in which she is supported and comforted was so amazingly touching.  The closing scene of Captain Brown bestowing a gift to one of his neighbors was so touching—at the end of this episode I was hooked. I knew I was in for the entire series.

Episode 2: August 1842

The episode begins with the young (and tardy) Dr. Harrison rushing off to church, eager to cross paths with a young girl with whom he’s taken an interest.  Other relationships are explored, and there’s much fussing about as the ladies of the community prepare for a very special garden party to be held at Lady Ludlow’s estate.  We get to know a poor family with a young boy yearning to get out of his situation and to get an education.  And a young female resident’s crush on the young doctor becomes apparent, setting up a series of misunderstandings that affect almost the entire community.  The news of the arrival of a railroad (and therefore much change in Cranford) leads to the death of a major character, which quite surprised me. This episode isn’t as light as the first, but an incident with a cow is quite amusing.

Episode 3: November 1842

This episode was touching and quite spellbinding in parts.  My heart ached in sadness as well as joy throughout the hour.  I dare not minimize its effect on me by a lot of words here.  I will say that when one character’s friend dies, I was more than teary-eyed.  I honestly wanted to sob.  My 10 year-old son was with me at that point, so I held it together in front of him.  Had he not been there, I probably would have been a mess.  It was an amazing, heartbreaking episode.

Episode 4: April 1843

If I could give this episode another title, it would probably be “Much Ado About Nothing”, at least in regard to the miscommunications that occur.  The machine of misunderstanding reaches a feverish point between many of the characters.  It’s clear that all of these well-meaning folk are just seeking out love and betrothals, but with the rumor mill being what it is, poor communication causes much confusion and dismay.  The episode has its light moments, but it feels more like a bridge episode, carrying us to the concluding hour as many characters begin to take on new paths in their lives.

Episode 5: May 1843

The final episode brings the series to its conclusion quite well.  Issues in relationships are resolved, and while tragedy strikes some, they rise above their challenging situations to triumph in their own way.  There’s a significant amount of tense, life-or-death drama here.  And with more than one main character dying during the previous episodes, I honestly didn’t know how everything would turn out.  Fortunately, the ending was lovely.  It wasn’t completely “happily ever after”, but a believable reality that left a fine aftertaste of joy.

Cranford was a delightful surprise.  I relished every moment, and those 5 hours on my Saturday flew by.  Having that block so much free time was rare, and I’m grateful for it.  I absolutely loved this miniseries, and I can’t wait to see the next production, Return to Cranford.

Of course as a book lover and member of this tour, I had to investigate Mrs. Gaskell’s work.  She’s written quite a few things, and I look forward to reading Cranford, Mr. Harrison’s Confessions and My Lady Ludlow, the three books upon which this series was based.  I’ve already downloaded a copy of Cranford to my computer.  It’s available for free from’s Kindle store.  I don’t own a Kindle, but the software to read it on a PC (or an iPhone) is available for free.

I thank Laurel Ann for including me on the tour, for without it I would still be in the dark about Mrs. Gaskell.  Had they lived in the same era, I’m sure Elizabeth Gaskell and Jane Austen would have enjoyed each others’ work.  This Janeite certainly did.

Now that you’ve stopped by The Calico Critic, follow this link to the next stop on the Elizabeth Gaskell Bicentenary Blog Tour by Regency Romantic.  Joanna is going to offer her review of the Gaskell novel Ruth from 1853 on


North and South (Complete Classics)As you visit each stop on the tour, be sure to leave a comment at each posting.  One commenter from these tour sites will win a copy of an unabridged audio book edition of North and South by Naxos AudioBooks read by Clare Willie.  The deadline for leaving comments on the participating sites is midnight Pacific time on October 7th.  One name will be drawn by from The Calico Critic and sent to Laurel Ann at, where she will draw from all the names sent in from the participating sites to determine the final winner.

**Winner Announced:  Annette made a comment over on Stiletto Storytime and was chosen to win.**

•    1.) Elizabeth Gaskell’s Life and Times: Vic – Jane Austen’s World

•    2.) Mary Barton (1848) Book: Kelly – Jane Austen Sequel Examiner
•    3.) Cranford (2007) Movie: Laura – The Calico Critic
•    4.) Ruth (1853) Book: Joanna (RegencyRomantic) -- Austenprose
•    5.) North and South (1854–5) Audio Book: Laurel Ann – Austenprose
•    6.) North and South (2004) Movie: Maria – Fly High
•    7.) Sylvia’s Lovers (1863) Book: Courtney – Stiletto Storytime
•    8.) Wives and Daughters (1865) Book: Katherine – November’s Autumn
•    9.) Wives and Daughters (1999) Movie: Elaine – Random Jottings
•    10.) The Life of Charlotte Bronte (1857) Book & (1973) Movie, The Brontes of Haworth: JaneGS – Reading, Writing, Working, Playing

•    11. Mr. Harrison’s Confessions (1851) Book: Alexandra – The Sleepless Reader
•    12. My Lady Ludlow (1859) Book: Alexandra – The Sleepless Reader
•    13. Cousin Phillis (1864) Book: Alexandra – The Sleepless Reader

•    14.) Your Gaskell Library – Links to MP3′s, ebooks, audio books, other downloads and reading resources available online: Janite Deb - Jane Austen in Vermont
•    15) Plymouth Grove - A Visit to Elizabeth Gaskell’s home in Manchester: Tony Grant – London Calling


  1. I loved watching Cranford. For some reason I felt I had been with my ideal grandmother and aunts. Thank you for this lovely review. Vic

  2. I laughed and cried as much as you did when I watched this series! I think they were able to bring out the light and shade of Gaskell's writing with this adaptation. Although I have yet to read Mr. Harrison's Confession and My Lady Ludlow.

    Thank you for such an engaging review! =)

  3. Happy Birthday Mrs. Gaskell! I loved this miniseries which was chockablock with English talent and visually stunning. I hope there is more to come in the way of adaptations of her work. Also glad to see that they are preserving her house in Manchester, England which had previously fallen into disrepair.

    Love the cat and the lace! Jenny Allworthy of

  4. Enjoyed your review. I ordered the Cranford series mostly because of my admiration for Judy Dench, and ended up a great admirer of Elizabeth Gaskell.

  5. Great review, sorry,reviews laura.

    I noticed how you got involved pretty quickly in the series. Great literature is great because it touches the reader with a real emotional experience. It makes you grow and adds to your personal experience.You learn something from it.

    What is amazing is that a great cast of actors and a brilliant script made the TV series touch you too.

  6. I love Mrs. Gaskell's description of the Cranford residents, "In the first place, Cranford is in possession of the Amazons; all the holders of houses above a certain rent are women." Amazons! It always makes me giggle.

    This lovely quaint adaptation has certainly brought international attention to Mrs. Gaskell with floods of tourists to her beloved village & hopefully new readers of her excellent books.

    Thanks for sharing.

  7. I've never read North & South. Looks like I've missed out.

  8. I loved hearing your opinion of the Cranford film, since you had never read any Gaskell. The film was my first exposure to her writing, and shortly after viewing it, I was involved in a Cranford read-along. I won't say anything about the novel right now, but I'd be interested to hear how you feel about it compared to the film.

  9. Looks good...First-time visitor.

    I am stopping from Cym Lowell's Book Review Party.

    Stop by mine if you like.

  10. I love hearing about how people discover Gaskell. Even more so than Austen, I think it's those marvelous adaptations that spark the interest, and Cranford was blessed with an absolutely brilliant cast.

    The bit with the lace is every bit as funny in print, btw.

    I hope you enjoy Cranford, the book--it was Gaskell's favorite, and the only one that she actually reread...

  11. When I first heard there was to be a TV mini-series based on Cranford, I wondered how on earth they would fill the episodes. Absolutely all I remembered of it was the hilarious episode with the cat and the lace - the first time I have ever seen any reference to bodily functions - even of a cat - in Victorian literature! When all the multifarious plot elements were unfolding, I went searching through my bookcases and ultimately discovered My Lady Ludlow and Mr. Harrison's Confession, which two novellas contail most of the plot.

  12. Thanks you for your lovely assessment of Cranford. I enjoyed it also, but am thrilled that I have introduced you to a new author who you enjoyed and want to read. Try North and South next. It is amazing, and as a Janeite Laura, you will see similarities. Thanks again for participating in the blog tour.

    Cheers, Laurel Ann

  13. I adored Cranford...and I am so very jealous of you getting to read all of Gaskell with fresh eyes! All of the adaptations for film of Gaskell's works, I think have been very well done. Enjoy!


  14. I enjoyed Cranford as well, although I will pretty much watch anything with Judi Dench in it. I also liked Simon Woods and Michel Gambon's performances.

  15. Thanks for the great review of Cranford by episode. I'm so happy that more people are being introduced to Mrs. Gaskell's work through this blog tour.

  16. I believe there are several of us whose first introduction to her works were the adaptations of her works (mine was Wives and Daughters), so it is good to know the miniseries has interested you.

    I cannot but admire what Sue Birtwistle, Susie Conklin and Heidi Thomas did by combining several Gaskell's stories inspired by her memories of Knutsford (the real Cranford) to create a miniseries.

    BTW, a Making of book is coming up this month.

    And I hope you like the Amazonian world of Cranford once you read the book, it is a great fun to notice the differences

  17. You don't have to enter me in the contest but I wanted to comment and say welcome to the wonderful world of Mrs. Gaskell! Cranford and Return to Cranford are both wonderful. I also loved the incident with the cat and the lace and the incident with the cow, Bessie dearest. Like you, I laughed and cried a lot. I wrote a review of the two mini-series on my blog. I also recommend Lark Rise to Candleford which is based on a novel/memoir of the Oxfordshire Victorian childhood of Flora Thompson. It's a lot like Cranford.



Related Posts with Thumbnails